List Archives

Thu Nov 29 12:03:09 GMT 2007

I think this is a very disturbing precedent. Especially considering I thought it was a moral duty to treat the ill and infirm without discrimination. As I recall as far back as the Napoleonic wars, the physicians of the Swiss Red Cross treated wounded French soldiers. In every war since it has been the custom to treat the opposing fighters who are wounded as well. The arguement that these are not soldiers, but criminals seems equally misguided. What if you treated a drug dealer who was shot selling drugs and his intention was to return to health to sell drugs? By this logic would you not be supporting the illegal drug trade? It a sad day for society when the nuetrality of a healthcare provider is comprimised by a court.

  Just my thoughts, (much simpler and condensed that others)
  Mike

Charles Brault <c_brault at yahoo.com> wrote:
  25 years for "conspiring" to treat the ennemy
Makes one wonder who is the terrorist exactly ! ?

... equals to condeming to death all medical personel in Iraq
... in order to send a strong message

Doctor sentenced in NY terrorism case 

By LARRY NEUMEISTER, Associated Press 

NEW YORK - A doctor convicted of conspiring to treat injured al-Qaida fighters was sentenced Wednesday 
to 25 years in prison, with the judge reasoning that a sentence to deter others was needed because terrorists 
cannot carry out their deadly aims without help. 

U.S. District Judge Loretta A. Preska noted Dr. Rafiq Sabir, 53, showed no remorse after his May conviction 
for conspiring to provide material support to terrorists by agreeing to treat injured al-Qaida members so they 
could return to Iraq to battle Americans.

The judge said there was "no reason to believe that this defendant has abandoned any criminal intentions."
She said terrorism offenses were among the most serious crimes prosecuted and required stern punishments.
"If not for assistance to terrorists, then terrorist acts would not take place," she said.

Just before the announcement of the sentence in a crowded courtroom, Sabir, of Boca Raton, Fla., insisted he 
was "completely innocent." He said a co-defendant, jazz musician and martial arts expert Tarik Shah, had duped 
him into taking an oath with an FBI agent who posed as an al-Qaida recruiter, never explaining that he was pledging 
loyalty to al-Qaida or its leader, Osama bin Laden. "I'm an extremely gullible man," he said.

Sabir said he learned more about Shah at his trial than he had learned in the previous 20 years when they had 
become close friends. He said he now realizes Shah tried to sell his services to al-Qaida.
"My intentions were entirely within the law," he said. "I had no idea I was being asked to be an al-Qaida member."
The judge said she concluded Sabir perjured himself when he testified during trial that he did not understand the 
accent of the FBI agent during the pledging ceremony and did not realize that "al-Qaida" was said or that references 
to "Osama" were about bin Laden.

Shah was recently sentenced to 15 years in prison in a deal with the government. A Brooklyn bookstore owner who 
pleaded guilty was sentenced to 13 years in prison. A Washington, D.C., cab driver has pleaded guilty and agreed 
to serve 15 years in prison.
--
trauma-list : TRAUMA.ORG
To change your settings or unsubscribe visit:
http://www.trauma.org/index.php?/community/

---------------------------------
Never miss a thing.   Make Yahoo your homepage.

List Archives

For your convenience, find the Trauma List Archive Below

Doctor sentenced in NY terrorism case