List Archives

Thu Aug 2 17:00:35 BST 2007

Dr. Mattox,

Thank you for this valuable information. This information can also be
used for meaningful discussions / learning purposes during hospital
disaster committee meetings. It may help to focus these types of
committees on practical disaster planning. I plan to share these and
other comments at our hospital Trauma Operations-Systems Committee and
our Disaster Committee. 

Regards,
Heidi

Heidi A. Hotz, RN, Trauma Program Manager
Department of Surgery
Cedars-Sinai Medical Center
8700 Beverly Blvd. 
Los Angeles, CA 90048

Office: 310-423-8732
Cell: 310-430-2649
Pager: 310-960-6341
Fax: 310-423-0139

http://www.csmc.edu/10163.html

-----Original Message-----
From: trauma-list-bounces at trauma.org
[mailto:trauma-list-bounces at trauma.org] On Behalf Of KMATTOX at aol.com
Sent: Thursday, August 02, 2007 8:51 AM
To: trauma-list at trauma.org; ccm-l at ccm-l.org
Subject: Summary Comments relating to the Minneapolis Disaster

1.    Congratulations to the EMS, emergency medicine,  and trauma
services at 
the hospitals in the Greater Minneapolis area, especially  the Hennepin 
County Hospital.    It appears that the trauma  system served as an
infrastructure 
for a disaster plan and the drills alerted  everyone and the system
WORKED.  
Congratulations

2.    As with ALL disasters the critical medical  problems are managed 
LOCALLY.   The success or failure of the critical  medical management is
dependent 
on the LOCAL preparedness.    Obviously, the LOCAL medical planners did
their 
job and the response was  fantastic.  THE SYSTEM WORKS.    I am so proud
of our 
 Trauma/EM/Critical Care infrastructures.     There is some  real
leadership 
across the country and across the world.    And  all of that leadership 
remains LOCAL.    During such times of  need that LOCAL leadership also
becomes 
a-political.   

3.    The reports did seem to indicate that the turn  out of EMS,
fireman, 
and medical personnel to the hospital was  "overwhelming."   Although
the 
eventual total numbers of  medical/surgical/trauma casualties was not
initially 
known, just as with 911  (and Oklahoma City, and Katrina in Houston),
MANY MORE 
medical personnel showed  up than were actually needed to care for the
number of 
patients who actually  needed attention.  Medical manpower management
must 
become a subject of  future conferences.   

4.    THE 10% RULE continues to be very  valid !  During the evening I 
calculated the number of "at risk"  people based on the number of cars
on the bridge 
at the time.  I came up with the number 600.   There were 60 injuries -
10%  
of the potential people at risk were actually injured.   This 10% rule
is 
uncannily reproducible in all the numbers I can find from most disasters
for  the 
past 30 years.  In addition, there appear to only be only 5 major
injuries 
(one tube thoracostomy for a penetrating injury to the chest,  three 
laparotomies for blunt injury, and one craniotomy).   5/60 =
approximately 10%.   The 
10% rule still holds.    This  10% rule was cited in several articles
after 
Katrina.   Only 10% of  the at risk people, actually become patients,
and of the 
patients, only 10%  actually have severe injuries.   For the medical
manpower 
manager, the  challenge becomes identifying that 1% of the regional
group.    

5.    The repeated call for blood following a  disaster, merely to give 
people something to do needs close analysis and an  alternate plan
developed.   
With most disasters, new blood donations  for that location is NOT
needed.   It 
should NOT be the local or  regional Red Cross that makes the call for
blood 
and other donations, but the  trauma center or the Regional Blood Center
in 
concert with the trauma  center.   It would be much more appropriate to
have 
potential donors  fill out "Commit for Life" donor cards, than just to
put out 
their arm to have  blood drawn which is then later lost to non-use, or
SOLD to a 
foreign country at  great profit by the business that drew the blood
during a 
crisis, when emotions  were high.   

6.    It is very obvious that outside medical help were  NOT needed.
Such 
outside medical help are almost never needed as has been  documented in
NYC, 
Oklahoma City, Houston, LA, San Antonio, Mexico City, Madrid,  London,
Washington 
DC, etc . etc , etc . etc .   As a matter of fact,  the outside help
often 
get in the way.    However, there are  other networking areas of
potential 
assistance, and information sharing that  should occur during real time
unfolding 
of a disaster.  The trauma network  and trauma centers within 100 miles
of the 
trauma center that took in the  injuries at the time of the Virginia
Tech 
shooting is one such beautiful  example.  They did not call or run off
to the 
hospital receiving the  patients, but stood ready to receive overflow,
or even 
existing stable patients  in order to free up needed local ICU beds.

7.    The power of an integrated collaborative network  via these two
list 
servers is tremendous, as long as we recognize that its  purpose is NOT
to go to 
the city of the disaster, to call the hospital in such  cities, etc.etc.
We 
must develop agendas and purposes for which our  powerful tools can be
used.  
Dr. Crippen made several meaningful  suggestions last night.    

8.    We ALL must continue to observe that the initial  information flow
is 
often exaggerated, or in error, and always  incomplete.   Developing a
way of 
dealing with the press is  essential.   It is obvious that whatever
city, 
community, village,  church, school, farm, etc, a disaster occurs in,
CNN and Fox 
News will be  there.  They will ALWAYS be there.     We can learn  from
what we 
saw last night.   

In my sending out messages last night as I received information was to
give  
a time line of what information was available, NOT for us to consider
going to 
 Minneapolis, but to give data to readers as to a process issue
involving non 
-  clinical people.    In many ways it was also a test to determine
just how 
we on this list can, would, and did respond.  We can now use those  
observations to build our integrated collaborative network.  After all,
that is what 
the Internet is.  

k

************************************** Get a sneak peek of the all-new
AOL at 
http://discover.aol.com/memed/aolcom30tour
--
trauma-list : TRAUMA.ORG
To change your settings or unsubscribe visit:
http://www.trauma.org/index.php?/community/
IMPORTANT WARNING: This message is intended for the use of the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged and confidential, the disclosure of which is governed by
applicable law.  If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or the employee or agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this information is STRICTLY PROHIBITED.

If you have received this message in error, please notify us immediately
by calling (310) 423-6428 and destroy the related message.  Thank You for your cooperation.

List Archives

For your convenience, find the Trauma List Archive Below

Summary Comments relating to the Minneapolis Disaster